Is dog boarding better than pet sitting for puppies?

For most puppies, boarding with training add-ons provides structure, socialization, and consistent routines that pet sitting can’t match.

Do you offer board-and-train near Fishers?

Yes. We offer training add-ons during boarding for obedience refreshers, leash manners, recall, and confidence building.

How do I book dog boarding in Fishers?

Call 317-603-2292 or use our online booking form to reserve your dates.

Dog Boarding vs. Pet Sitting in Fishers: Which Is Right for Your Dog?

Jerry Wilson

September 19, 2025

If you're a dog owner in Fishers, Indiana, you've probably faced the question: Should I board my dog or hire a pet sitter? Both options have pros and cons, but the right choice depends on your dog's personality, routine, and your goals as an owner. At Big N' Small Paws 317, we provide dog boarding with training add-ons that go beyond simple care, helping your pup thrive while you're away. Let's break down the differences so you can make the best decision.

What Is Pet Sitting?

Pet sitting typically means hiring someone to come into your home to feed, walk, and check on your dog while you're gone.
Pros of Pet Sitting:

Your dog stays in a familiar environment
No travel stress for your pup
Good for short trips

Cons of Pet Sitting:

Limited supervision (often just 1–2 visits per day)
Less socialization and stimulation
No structured training or enrichment

What Is Dog Boarding in Fishers?

Dog boarding involves bringing your dog to a professional facility where they stay overnight with structured care, play, and supervision. At Big N' Small Paws 317, boarding can be combined with obedience refreshers, leash manners, and puppy training add-ons.
Pros of Dog Boarding:

24/7 care and supervision
Social play with other dogs
Daily walks, enrichment, and structure
Optional training programs for better behavior
Professional staff who specialize in dogs

Cons of Dog Boarding:

New environment (though dogs usually adjust quickly)
Requires vaccinations and paperwork

Which Option Fits Your Dog Best?

For puppies → Boarding with training provides structure and routine.
For social dogs → Boarding offers playtime and interaction.
For reactive or anxious dogs → Training add-ons during boarding can reduce stress and build confidence.
For dogs who struggle in new environments → Pet sitting may work for very short trips, but it lacks enrichment.

Why Fishers Dog Owners Choose Big N’ Small Paws 317

Premium boarding suites (Private, Governor, Presidential)
Add-on obedience training during the stay
Professional grooming and daycare options
Serving Fishers, Indianapolis, Carmel, Westfield, and Noblesville

Dog waiting at home during pet sitting in Fishers Indiana compared to boarding at Big N’ Small Paws

Final Thoughts

Both pet sitting and dog boarding serve a purpose, but if you want your dog to come home happy, enriched, and better behaved, professional dog boarding with training in Fishers is the smarter choice.